A Grimm History, And They Ain’t Disney Tales
Folklore tropes and historical storytelling first hooked me at university, where my naïve heart discovered that the bedtime canon is a crime scene in disguise.
Little Red Riding Hood as it turns out in a few variations, was a fair maiden tricked into eating Nanna steaks quicker than you can say: Fava Beans and nice Chianti. Enticed to perform a striptease for the seductive wolf, all because the poor lass stopped to smell the flowers. Lesson: beware the cunning gentleman and always obey your parents.
That rude awakening blew the icing sugar off every cupcake I’d been told about fairy tales, and I’ve been sweeping up the crumbs ever since.
To the people who told them, those tales were treasured folklore, shared at firesides, weddings, harvest feasts, and long winter nights, carrying communal identity, gallows humour, superstition and hard-won advice. They evolved and changed, adapted and merged like all stories. But modern readers inherit them through the double filter of the Brothers Grimm and the Disney corporation.
Curious? Read on, but be warned; it contains some gruesome tidbits and is not for the faint of heart.
The Brothers Grimm, Jacob and Wilhelm, were court librarians and academics turned linguists, collected ancient folk tales, tweaked them and went on to publish Kinder- und Hausmärchen in 1812 to bottle what they called the Volksgeist, the people’s spirit.
Their first edition was filled with tales of cannibal mothers, sexual violence, mutilated toes and red-hot iron shoes. Reviewers were horrified.
Take Cinderella. Long before mice could harmonise, the German Aschenputtel left its heroine praying at her mother’s grave while a white dove shook down gowns of silver and gold. There is no fairy godmother; the magic grows from grief.
At the slipper test one stepsister hacks off her toes, the other her heel; blood betrays them, and wedding doves later peck out their eyes (Tatar 2003). Disney kept the slipper but traded ancestral pain for a genial wand and a blue ball gown. Agency slips away with the amputated toes.
Sleeping Beauty fares no better.
Giambattista Basile’s Neapolitan version, Sun, Moon and Talia (1634), puts its heroine into a catatonic sleep, then lets a wandering king assault her; twins are born, and she wakes only when one infant sucks a flax splinter from her finger.
Perrault toned the assault into an ambiguous kiss but retained a cannibal ogress mother-in-law. The Grimms’ Little Briar Rose shaved off the assault, twins and ogress, leaving a neat century-long snooze that ends when the clock, not a princely kiss, says so.
Disney re-injected a kiss, christened evil Maleficent and unleashed a dragon. Romance sells; dynastic violation does not.
Snow White began as a tale of beauty consumed by envy literally.
In the 1812 Grimm text, the queen demands Snow White’s lungs and liver for supper, then strangles the girl with a laced bodice and finishes her off with a poisoned comb before luring her to eat a poisoned apple.
A prince purchases the glass coffin; his servants stumble, the apple dislodges, Snow White lives, and the queen is forced to dance in red-hot shoes until she dies (Warner 1996).
The dwarves? Historians guess Dopey and Grumpy were actually child miners. Disney shaved the story clean: the cannibal hunger, the torture dance, and the coffin commerce vanish, replaced by a quick kiss and a cliff tumble.
Not every Disney classic is a Grimm Bro production.
Hans Christian Andersen’s Little Mermaid (1837) is more edgy and existential. Andersen’s mermaid swaps her tongue for legs that feel like knives, fails to win the prince, refuses murder to save herself and dissolves into sea foam, rewarded only with the hope of an immortal soul.
Disney ditches the knives and the foam, restores her voice, slays the sea witch and crowns a royal wedding amid fireworks. The mermaid’s sacrificial longing becomes teenage self-expression choreographed by a Caribbean crab.
Wait for it…Beauty and the Beast is essentially a Stockholm Syndrome / Arranged Marriage tale from 1740.
Coined as a French romance by writer Madame de Villeneuve’ it was later shortened by Jeanne-Marie Leprince de Beaumont. In both, Belle is bartered to settle her father’s debt and agrees to marriage out of filial duty, praying the beast’s gentleness will outlast his power.
Disney’s 1991 version neutralises the transaction, recasts captivity as heroic self-sacrifice and marshals singing crockery to explain that love cures abuse.
Don’t even get me started on Hansel and Gretel. You think a witch trying to fatten up a little boy is gruesome? Want the real tea? The Great Famine of Medieval times had parents eating or abandoning their kids in the forest. Sheesh.
So, why file down the teeth?
For most of European history, children were treated as small, inexperienced adults. Hard labour was expected of children, death rates were high, and children received the same punishments as their elders.
The early Industrial Revolution swept in, bringing rising wages, cheaper food and new child labour laws that hauled youngsters off factory floors and into classrooms and nurseries.
Once kids were seen as little people to be cherished rather than tiny wage-earners, society insisted its folktales get a soft-focus makeover—so the Brothers Grimm bowed to middle-class morality and gave the old stories a kind of Tarantino-meets-Tim-Burton rewrite.
Nineteenth-century publishers needed tales that reinforced obedience, Christian virtue and patriarchal order for an emerging bourgeois audience. Twentieth-century studios needed marketable heroines, clear villains, catchy songs and plush toys. Moral complexity doesn’t fit on a lunch box lid.
Fast forward to 2025, here we are streaming splatter-series before breakfast, binging true-crime podcasts on the commute.
Dear reader, a century of colonial sanitising and candy-coated fairy tales never cured our human appetite for darkness. You don’t have to look very far to see that the tropes and archetypes of old are alive and well.
Disney’s castles still glitter, but listen closely, and you will hear the crunch of bones beneath the stone floors. Behind every slipper, spindle and apple, the old shadows flicker, muttering that enchantment never comes free and the safest path through the forest is never entirely safe.
Let’s face it, the world would be a little more beige without Sebastian and Mrs. Potts. I’ve been to Disneyland; it is the Happiest Place on Earth- I totally agree. But as for the patriarchal princes rescuing the princesses? Well, that’s a blog for another day…
Works Cited
Tatar, M. (2003) The Hard Facts of the Grimms’ Fairy Tales. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Available at: https://books.google.com/books/about/The_Hard_Facts_of_the_Grimms_Fairy_Tales.html?id=lTtMH_ezI4UC(Accessed: 6 May 2025). Google Books
Warner, M. (1996) From the Beast to the Blonde: On Fairy Tales and Their Tellers. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.Available at: https://books.google.com/books/about/From_the_Beast_to_the_Blonde.html?id=B8NO-T2lOqMC(Accessed: 6 May 2025). Google Books
Zipes, J. (2002) Breaking the Magic Spell: Radical Theories of Folk and Fairy Tales (rev. ed.). Lexington, KY: University Press of Kentucky. Available at: https://books.google.com/books/about/Breaking_the_Magic_Spell.html?id=SGY1EAAAQBAJ (Accessed: 6 May 2025). Google Books
Bettelheim, B. (1989) The Uses of Enchantment: The Meaning and Importance of Fairy Tales. New York: Vintage Books.Available at: https://books.google.com/books/about/The_Uses_of_Enchantment.html?id=7WiODQAAQBAJ (Accessed: 6 May 2025). Google Books
Pullman, P. (2012) Fairy Tales from the Brothers Grimm: A New English Version. London: Viking. Available at: https://books.google.com/books/about/Fairy_Tales_from_the_Brothers_Grimm.html?id=HBb-gj7vqWYC (Accessed: 6 May 2025)
More blogs & Essays
What the Lobster Taught Me About Growth
A lobster, a dash of existential discomfort, when a metaphor gets under your skin and sends you down a rabbit hole about growth, hiding, and being held.
Sweet Sadness and Skittles
My brain is a busy and complex ideas factory. It rebels and runs in different directions. Meditation and being in flow help to tame it…sometimes.
Little Mouse
This essay was inspired by Plato's Cave, with a dash of country town childhood and swift growth after severe life changing moments. This has been a favourite for readers and as always, everyone seems to get their own story from it. With love xThere was a little mouse,...
Schedule an Event
media@kbeliza.com
We acknowledge the traditional custodians of the land on which we work, the Kulin peoples. We pay our respect to elders past present and emerging, we acknowledge and and all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders. The land we on which we live, breathe, work, eat and sleep always was and always will be Aboriginal land. KB Eliza supports the
Contact Author
media@kbeliza.com